Long Island Gets a Second Cheeburger! Farmingdale marks the second Cheeburger Cheeburger location on Long Island and the sixth in the great State of New York. The first Long Island Cheeburger location was Plainview, owned and operated by Steve Seltzer. Now Steve and his Plainview General Manager, Tom Falcone, will own and operate the new Farmingdale restaurant. Steve and Tom obviously know what their neighbors in Long Island love to eat most... Cheeburgers! Stop in at 228 Airport Plaza Boulevard in Farmingdale and say "Hello" to Steve, Tom, and the whole gang.